7 Comments

A superb display of a broad base of (historical) knowledge, and a mind sharpened for synthesis—I applaud you in possessing this rare combination. Great article.

Expand full comment
author

Thank you Tyler, very kind.

Expand full comment

That's a hugely comprehensive article, thank you.

Expand full comment

I suddenly had the image of a campaign prosecuted entirely by sealed envelope, with conditions printed on each one for when and in what order to open, like a pre-programmed decision tree that has to be handed out before the fight even begins.

Expand full comment
author

Simplicity first! A decision tree for the entire campaign (vs. individual components in one phase) is probably possible in some cases, but that makes it vulnerable to the unforeseen.

Expand full comment

A favorite conversation with a U.S. Army Major while working as a civilian Subject Matter Expert for an Army exercise was his answer that “we have a plan so that we know what we are deviating from.”

Expand full comment

It is impractical, but it could be a fun game or thought experiment. The unforseen will really mess things up, true.

Expand full comment